The New York Giants are facing quarterback questions again, but don’t expect Jameis Winston to be part of any mid-season fire sale. Despite his uncertain role behind Russell Wilson and rookie Jaxson Dart, insiders say Winston’s value to the Giants goes far beyond the field.
The Veteran QB Who’s Not on the Trade Block
Winston has been in the league for a decade, bouncing from starter to backup, and everything in between. But in New York, his presence is more intentional than improvisational.
The Giants didn’t just scoop him up for insurance. They made a calculated move when they signed him to a two-year, $8 million contract this offseason. And according to Giants insider Art Stapleton, the team isn’t looking to flip him for a mid-round pick or some future value.
“They’re not trading Jameis unless someone makes them a Godfather offer,” Stapleton said on X.
It’s a rare kind of statement in the NFL, especially for a quarterback not locked into a starting job. But it tells you everything about what Winston represents to this team — stability, leadership, and maybe even a long-term backup plan.
Winston’s Role Isn’t Just About the Depth Chart
Russell Wilson is the starter, and Jaxson Dart is the rookie hopeful. That leaves Winston in a somewhat murky No. 2 or No. 3 role. Still, the Giants aren’t thinking about that in traditional terms.
Winston brings experience. He brings maturity. He brings the kind of locker room voice that coaches love, even if fans overlook it.
There was early speculation that Winston might compete for the starting job. Some reports suggested he had early support inside the building. But once Wilson was signed, Head Coach Brian Daboll made it clear: Wilson’s starting. End of discussion.
Even if Winston doesn’t win the backup job outright, his value off the field might be worth just as much.
Why Teams Might Come Calling Anyway
Quarterbacks get hurt. That’s just reality in the NFL.
Last season, Winston was thrust into the starting role in Cleveland after multiple injuries hit the Browns’ QB room. He started seven games, completed 61% of his passes, and threw for 2,121 yards with 13 touchdowns. He also tossed 12 interceptions — because, well, it’s still Jameis.
That kind of stat line? Not perfect. But for a team in panic mode mid-season, it’s more than serviceable.
A few examples of situations that could spark interest:
-
A contending team loses their starter for 4–6 weeks and doesn’t trust their backup
-
A team with a young, unsteady starter needs a veteran fallback
-
A coaching staff looks for leadership in a crumbling locker room
Winston checks all those boxes — and at $4 million a year, he’s affordable, too.
Giants Have a Long-Term QB Vision—And Winston’s in It
There’s something telling about how the Giants are talking about 2026 already.
Stapleton’s comment wasn’t just about this season. He wrote, “If all goes as planned, Dart and Jameis 1-2 in 2026.”
That suggests the team sees Winston not as a placeholder, but as part of the succession plan. Wilson might be the present, but he’s also 36. His deal is short-term, and nothing guarantees he finishes the season, much less starts in 2026.
Winston is only 31. That’s not ancient for a quarterback. And with the NFL’s shifting attitude toward backups — think Jacoby Brissett, Andy Dalton, or even Tyrod Taylor — teams are realizing how crucial the No. 2 guy is.
This isn’t just about throwing passes. It’s about reading defenses, mentoring young players, and keeping the QB room steady through rough weeks.
Giants Want Stability, Not a Fire Drill
So why not trade Winston if someone offers a 4th-rounder? Or even a 3rd?
Simple: the Giants don’t want chaos if Wilson goes down. And they’re not handing the reins to Dart too early unless absolutely necessary. Keeping Winston in the building is about more than injury insurance. It’s about keeping the machine running smoothly.
He’s reliable. He’s respected. And most importantly, he’s cheap.
Unless a team comes in swinging with a truly eye-popping deal — something like a 2nd-rounder or a win-now defensive starter — the Giants aren’t picking up the phone. They’re not even reaching for it.
Winston may not be the headline act in New York, but he’s playing a much bigger part than people realize.
