The New York Mets’ blockbuster acquisition of Juan Soto has already sent shockwaves through the MLB offseason. Soto, one of baseball’s premier talents, adds undeniable firepower to an already promising lineup. However, this significant move leaves Mets fans and analysts speculating: what’s the next step for a team chasing a World Series title?
The Mets still have a glaring need to address their infield, particularly at the corners. With Pete Alonso’s potential departure looming, the team faces decisions that could define their 2025 season. Enter Nolan Arenado, the St. Louis Cardinals’ superstar third baseman, whose name is now at the forefront of trade discussions.
A Corner Infielder is Priority One
The Mets’ first base situation remains uncertain. Pete Alonso’s future with the team is hanging in the balance, and the market for first basemen this offseason is slim. While Mark Vientos could be a stopgap solution at first, the Mets appear more interested in bolstering their infield with a significant upgrade at third base.
Nolan Arenado, widely regarded as one of baseball’s best defensive players, is the standout option. Adding Arenado wouldn’t just strengthen the Mets’ infield defensively; his offensive prowess would provide a major boost to a team already poised for contention.
Why Nolan Arenado is a Perfect Fit
Arenado has made it clear he’s willing to waive his no-trade clause for the Mets, signaling mutual interest in a potential deal. His glove at the hot corner is unmatched, and pairing him with Francisco Lindor would create one of the league’s best defensive left sides. Arenado’s consistent offensive production would also alleviate pressure on the Mets’ lineup, giving them a dependable middle-of-the-order presence.
The Mets’ current third baseman, Brett Baty, struggled offensively and defensively in 2024, prompting doubts about his ability to hold the position long-term. Arenado represents a clear and immediate upgrade.
What Would a Trade for Arenado Look Like?
Thomas Gauvain of Redbird Rants recently proposed a hypothetical trade that sends Arenado to the Mets. Here’s the deal:
New York Mets Receive:
- 3B Nolan Arenado
- $15 million
St. Louis Cardinals Receive:
- RHP Jonah Tong
Gauvain’s pitch suggests that Arenado could come at a relatively low cost for the Mets in terms of prospects. Jonah Tong, a young pitcher with a powerful fastball, would head to St. Louis as the centerpiece of the deal. Meanwhile, the Cardinals offload over $30 million of Arenado’s remaining $52 million contract, freeing up financial flexibility for their roster rebuild.
Why This Deal Works for Both Sides
For the Mets:
- Arenado solidifies third base, creating an elite defensive pairing with Lindor.
- The move preserves payroll flexibility for additional upgrades, especially in the starting rotation.
- By avoiding the expensive free-agent market, the Mets reduce financial risk.
For the Cardinals:
- Shedding Arenado’s contract allows St. Louis to reallocate resources toward rebuilding.
- They gain a promising young arm in Jonah Tong, who could become a key piece in their future pitching staff.
The financial element of the deal also plays a crucial role. With the Cardinals contributing $15 million, the Mets would absorb Arenado’s contract at a manageable rate, keeping their sights set on long-term sustainability.
What About Pete Alonso?
Alonso’s uncertain future adds complexity to the Mets’ offseason plans. If Alonso departs, the Mets may explore multiple avenues to address their infield needs. Arenado’s addition could shift Mark Vientos to first base, offering a temporary solution. However, the Mets would still need to plan for a long-term replacement at first.
Alonso’s potential exit also creates opportunities for the Mets to explore free agency or trades for other impact players. While rumors swirl around Alex Bregman and other big names, Arenado’s availability makes him a more cost-effective and immediate solution.
Mets’ Big Picture: Building for 2025 and Beyond
Adding Soto and potentially Arenado shows the Mets are all-in on creating a championship-caliber roster. These moves demonstrate a commitment to winning without overextending financially, a delicate balance for any team with World Series aspirations.
The Mets’ focus on upgrading their rotation further underscores their strategy. By avoiding costly long-term contracts with free agents like Alonso, they retain the flexibility to invest heavily in pitching. Building a team capable of contending in 2025 requires more than one star player; it demands a balanced roster with depth in every area.
Final Thoughts
The Mets’ offseason strategy is shaping up to be one of the most fascinating storylines in baseball. With Juan Soto now anchoring their lineup, the potential addition of Nolan Arenado would push the team into elite territory. This calculated, forward-thinking approach reflects a franchise determined to return to championship glory.
For now, Mets fans wait with bated breath as trade talks and rumors swirl. One thing is clear: New York isn’t done making headlines this offseason.
