In a recent legal development, the Federal Court convened to deliberate on the costs associated with Bruce Lehrmann’s failed defamation case against Network Ten and journalist Lisa Wilkinson. The case, which unfolded over a series of hearings, has significant implications for both parties involved. Let’s delve into the details.
Bruce Lehrmann, a central figure in this legal battle, had previously launched a defamation lawsuit against Network Ten and Lisa Wilkinson. The case stemmed from allegations made by Lehrmann and the subsequent response by the media company and the journalist. However, Justice Michael Lee’s recent judgment has shed light on critical aspects of the case.
- Rape Allegations: Justice Lee found, on the balance of probabilities, that Lehrmann did rape Brittany Higgins at Parliament House in 2019. The court established that Lehrmann and Higgins had engaged in sexual activity in the office of Senator Linda Reynolds, where Higgins did not provide consent. Lehrmann’s indifference to her consent further compounded the situation.
- Defamatory Imputations: Network Ten and Lisa Wilkinson faced allegations of defamation by Lehrmann. However, Justice Lee ruled that the defamatory imputations made by the media company and the journalist were substantially true. This finding effectively quashed Lehrmann’s defamation lawsuit.
Implications and Costs
- Appeal Prospects: Lehrmann is now set to appeal the Federal Court’s defamation judgment. The costs hearing aims to determine the financial implications for both parties.
- Network Ten’s Conduct: During the proceedings, Network Ten’s conduct came under scrutiny. Justice Lee inquired about statements made by the media company, emphasizing that they did not represent a “considered view” informed by external legal advice. The court also discussed the impact of Lisa Wilkinson’s Logies speech in 2022, which led to delays in Lehrmann’s criminal trial
- The costs hearing remains ongoing, and Justice Lee has reserved his decision on the matter. As the legal landscape continues to evolve, the ramifications of this case reverberate through the media industry and beyond. Stay tuned for further updates.
