A sequel hasn’t even been confirmed yet, but Hogwarts Legacy fans are already debating who should step into the villain role—Sebastian Sallow is the name on everyone’s lips.
It’s been just over two years since Hogwarts Legacy swept onto the scene in February 2023, selling more copies than Elden Ring and quickly cementing itself as a fan favorite. And while the future of the franchise is still technically uncertain, that hasn’t stopped players from dreaming big—and arguing even bigger.
The Sequel We’re All Pretending Has Already Been Announced
Technically, Warner Bros. hasn’t given Hogwarts Legacy 2 the green light. Not officially. Not yet. But fans are talking about it like it’s inevitable.
Why wouldn’t they? The first game raked in cash like it had a Niffler running the books. It became the best-selling game of 2023, leaving industry giants in the dust. Despite that, Warner Bros. pulled the plug on any story DLC plans for the original game—a decision that still baffles longtime fans.
And yet, whispers from inside Warner Bros. suggest that the next installment might not just be a return to Hogwarts in the 1800s. Some hints point to a potential shift to a more modern era, perhaps aligning with the rebooted Harry Potter HBO series that’s still in development.That could change everything.
Reddit Threads, Fan Fictions, and One Slytherin in the Spotlight
Fans aren’t just sitting around waiting. Over on Reddit, one simple question kicked off a wildfire of speculation: “What would you rather see in a sequel to Hogwarts Legacy?”
The answers? All over the place—but one name kept popping up. Sebastian Sallow.
Environmental_Poem68 commented, “I wanna play Sebastian Sallow’s story!” And they’re definitely not alone. The Slytherin student was already a fan favorite thanks to his complex backstory, morally grey decisions, and, well… the fact that he wasn’t afraid to dabble in the Dark Arts.
That last part? Yeah, it’s a bit of a problem. Or maybe the perfect ingredient for a great villain.
Why Sebastian Sallow Just Might Work as the Villain
Let’s be clear: Sebastian isn’t exactly Voldemort material. He’s not the Dark Lord. But he’s complicated. And complicated can be interesting.
Here’s a quick look at what makes Sebastian such a strong candidate:
-
Practiced all three Unforgivable Curses without hesitation.
-
Sacrificed friendships in pursuit of forbidden knowledge.
-
Manipulated those closest to him—sometimes for noble reasons, sometimes not.
But fans love him anyway. He’s the kind of character who lives in the grey area, and that’s exactly where great villains usually come from.
Is the Timeline the Real Key?
All of this debate hinges on one very big unknown: when will the sequel take place?
If Hogwarts Legacy 2 picks up immediately after the events of the first game—say, the sixth academic year—it makes sense for Sebastian to be part of the story. Maybe even central to it. But if we’re jumping forward a few decades? Then he’s either long gone or significantly older, which makes for a very different kind of villain story.
Some fans are hoping for a continuation. Others want a clean slate, perhaps in a different location or magical school altogether. Durmstrang? Beauxbatons? The fan wishlist is extensive.
Just one sentence here: It all comes down to time.
What Do the Fans Really Want?
Everyone’s got their own wishlist for the sequel. Some are dreaming about expanded maps and new mechanics, others are already scripting entire fan fiction arcs in their heads. But here’s a breakdown of the top community hopes so far:
| Feature Request | Fan Interest Level |
|---|---|
| Sixth academic year | Very High |
| Larger open-world map | High |
| New magical school | Moderate to High |
| Playable Sebastian story | Extremely High |
| Modern-day Hogwarts | Mixed |
The numbers don’t lie. While there’s a clear hunger for a richer, broader experience, Sebastian Sallow remains the emotional centerpiece for a large chunk of the fandom.
Avalanche’s Silence Is Getting Loud
Avalanche Software, the studio behind Hogwarts Legacy, has been mum on any sequel details. Not a peep. It’s driving fans a little bit crazy.
Warner Bros. throwing cold water on any hopes of DLC didn’t help either. So now, fans are left theorizing, arguing, and writing wishful Reddit posts like it’s their full-time job.And honestly? Who can blame them?
It’s hard not to get swept up in it. Whether it’s the desire to finally play as an older Sebastian, the curiosity of what a modern Hogwarts might look like, or just the thrill of imagining new Dark Arts quests—we’re all hooked.It’s been two years. Feels like longer, doesn’t it?
